Audit implicates Senior Principal Martha Mbugua in administrative lapses, irregular fees and capitation grant discrepancies at Alliance Girls High School



The most recent auditor general's report for Alliance Girls High School, covering the year ending June 30, 2024, has uncovered several instances of financial mismanagement and malpractice.

The report indicates that the ultimate responsibility lies with the principal, Martha Mbugua, who serves as the CEO of the institution.

 

IRREGULAR LNCREASE OF SCHOOL FEES

The receipts and payments statement illustrates the income of the school fund, which includes parents' contributions totaling Kshs.131,824,577, as detailed in the financial statements.

This amount encompasses a self-sponsored contribution of Kshs.43,122,592. However, an examination of the fee guidelines for self-sponsored students indicated a deviation from the school fees stipulated for Category A - Boarding Schools Fees Structure, which is Kshs.53,554, as issued by the Ministry of Education in Circular Ref. No. IIOE - HQS/3/1 Ol18l(112) dated 15 November 2022.

The School charged Kshs.150,000, resulting in an unauthorized fee increase of Kshs.96,446 per student. Furthermore, the School failed to provide documentary proof of the Cabinet Secretary's approval for these additional charges, as mandated by Regulation 44 of the Basic Education Regulations, 2015.

LACK OF A PARENTS TEACHERS ASSOCIATION

The School lacked a Parents Teachers Association (PTA), which is mandated by Section 55 (2) of the Basic Education Act, 2013.

Consequently, the School was unable to receive support from the Parents Teachers Association for the Board of Management in areas such as enhancing student well-being, fostering teacher-parent relations, providing advice on fundraising, motivating performance, supervising development projects, and aiding with student discipline and staff welfare.

Under these circumstances, Management was in violation of the law.

 

LACK OF AN APPROVED PROCUREMENT PLAN

The statement detailing receipts and payments indicates total amounts of Kshs.178,492,656 and Kshs.154,903,490 for receipts and payments, respectively.

However, throughout the year in question, Management failed to develop an annual procurement plan as a component of the annual budget preparation process.

This action was in violation of Regulation 40 of the Public Procurement and Asset Disposal Regulations, 2020, which mandates that a procuring entity must create a procurement plan for each financial year as part of the annual budget preparation process.

 

NON-COMPLIANCE WITH THE ONE-THIRD RULE ON BASIC SALARY

The receipts and payments statement indicates a total of Kshs.149,382,725 allocated for boarding and school fund payments, which encompasses Kshs.38,273,071 pertaining to gross salary payments as detailed in the financial statements.

An examination of the School's payrolls disclosed that numerous employees received a net salary that was less than one-third (1/3) of their basic pay, in violation of Section 19(3) of the Employment Act, 2007.

This section stipulates that the total amount of deductions an employer may make from an employee's wages at any given time must not exceed two-thirds of those wages. Instances of non-compliant salary payments were observed over several months throughout the financial year under review.

 

FUNDING OF CAPITATION GRANTS

The statement of receipts and payments illustrates the capitation grants allocated for tuition, operational expenses, and infrastructure, amounting to Kshs. 1,990,503, Kshs. 6,516,574, and Kshs. 3,152,500, respectively, as detailed in the financial statements.

During the financial year, NEMIS reported a total of eight hundred and twenty-three (823) students, whereas the enrolment records submitted by the School indicated a total of seven hundred and forty-six (746) students, leading to an unexplained discrepancy of seventy-seven (77) students.

Consequently, due to these variances, the School received over-funding amounting to Kshs. 1,090,872. In light of these circumstances, the over-funding of the School may have adversely impacted service delivery to other schools that did not receive capitation for their students.

FAILURE TO TRANSFER INFRASTRUCTURE FUNDS FROM OPERATIONS BANK ACCOUNT

The receipts and payments statement indicates that the infrastructure grants total Kshs.3,152,500, as detailed in the financial statements from the Ministry of Education, which were credited to the operations bank account.

These infrastructure grants were intended to be transferred to the infrastructure bank account for the maintenance and enhancement of the School's facilities. However, no funds were transferred to the infrastructure account, resulting in the entire balance of Kshs.3,152,500 remaining in the operations account as of 30 June 2024.

This situation is in violation of The Ministry of Education Circular Ref. No. MOE.HQS1316136 dated 14th January 2021, which mandated that infrastructure grants, along with maintenance and improvement funds, should be transferred to the school infrastructure account within fifteen (15) days of receiving the funds in the operations account.

BOARD OF MANAGEMENT

An examination of the records indicated that the School Board of Management was composed of ten (10) members. Nevertheless, it was deficient in representation from essential categories as mandated by Section 56 of the Basic Education Act, 2013.

In particular, the Board failed to include six (6) individuals elected to represent parents within the School, three (3) members to represent sponsors, one (1) member for special needs, one (1) individual for special interest groups, and a representative from the students' council serving as an ex officio member.

This lack of compliance undermines the inclusivity and diversity that the Act aims to promote and could negatively affect effective decision-making and the representation of all stakeholders in the governance of the School.

 

Comments