Appeal dismissed: Nairobi West Hospital must compensate woman whose ovaries were removed without consent


Patients seeking gynecological services at Nairobi West Hospital are advised to ensure they request qualified gynecologists prior to any surgical procedures. This caution arises from the fact that the hospital does not employ permanently qualified gynecologists capable of performing serious operations; instead, they engage consultants who may not possess full qualifications.

Today, we disclose a case involving a female patient who visited Nairobi West Hospital and was assigned to a privately contracted consultant. This consultant negligently removed the patient’s ovaries, resulting in irreversible harm, specifically the loss of fertility.

  Since September 2018, a female patient (name withheld) was referred to Nairobi West Hospital due to complaints of abdominal pain. After diagnostic tests, she was diagnosed with ascites. She subsequently underwent surgery conducted by an independent consultant specialist operating at Nairobi West Hospital. A complaint was later filed with the Kenya Medical Practitioners and Dentists Council (the Council), alleging that the consultant negligently removed the patient’s ovaries without obtaining proper consent, contrary to the prior agreement. It was also claimed that this negligence led to irreversible harm, namely the loss of fertility. In its ruling on June 10, 2021, the Council identified faults in the consultant doctor’s conduct, particularly concerning the absence of informed consent and poor clinical decision-making. The Council held the Appellant hospital vicariously liable for the medical negligence attributed to the consultant doctor, a consultant gynecologist, and imposed a fine of Kshs. 250,000. Dissatisfied with the Council’s ruling, Nairobi West Hospital filed an appeal challenging both the factual and legal grounds, asserting that the Council misunderstood the relevant legal framework governing liability in medical practice.
Nairobi West Hospital argued that it cannot be held liable for the actions of independent consultants, asserting that vicarious liability arises only when an employment relationship exists or when the hospital has control over the practitioner’s work. The patient stated that all payments were directed to the hospital and asserted that hospitals have a non-delegable duty of care towards their patients. She contended that Nairobi West Hospital cannot evade liability by designating the doctor as a 'consultant.' The judge observed that it is evident that hospitals have a non-delegable duty of care to their patients and, as such, cannot avoid liability by delegating responsibilities to employees or independent contractors. This indicates that hospitals are vicariously liable for all medical professionals operating within their system. The judge further noted that the patient was admitted and treated at the hospital, underwent surgery there, and that payments were made to the hospital. The records also indicate that the patient did not independently choose the doctor, as the consultant was the head of the department within the hospital. In a ruling by Judge W.A. Okwany dated April 16, 2026, it states, 'After a thorough examination of the facts of this case and considering the findings I have made in this judgment, I conclude that the decision by the Council was legally and factually sound.' In rejecting the appeal from Nairobi West Hospital, the judge remarked, 'Consequently, I find that the current appeal lacks merit, and I hereby issue the following final orders: a. The Appeal is dismissed in its entirety. b. The decision of the Kenya Medical Practitioners and Dentists Council dated June 10, 2021, is upheld. c. The Appellant is found vicariously liable for the negligence of the 2nd Respondent.

Comments