Leadership Turmoil and Financial Irregularities at Stella Maris Othaya Girls' High School


HIGHLIGHTS

Allegations of Authoritarian Governance and Community Backlash

Academic and Disciplinary Decline Amid Controversy

Financial Mismanagement: Outstanding Debts and Procurement Breaches

Stakeholders Demand Accountability and Transparency

Challenges in School Governance: Political Influence and Ethical Questions

Audit Reveals Procurement Violations and Levy Non-Compliance

Unaddressed Student Welfare Concerns and Calls for Clarification

Structural and Financial Oversights Threaten School Stability

 

Stella Maris Othaya Girls' High School's Irene Kamau finds herself in a challenging situation as stakeholders, parents, members of the Parents Association, and the Board of Management have collectively called for her immediate transfer. A member of the Parents Association, who spoke to us on the condition of anonymity due to fear of retaliation, alleged that Madam Kamau governs the school with an iron fist, employing coercion, threats, and intimidation. She reportedly shows a lack of respect for teachers, board members, non-teaching staff, and parents. Furthermore, she asserts that she has political connections and considers herself untouchable, claiming to be a close ally of Nyeri Governor Mutahi Kahiga. It has been reported that she boasts about her ability to remain in her position, stating that she can only be transferred if she chooses to leave, but cannot be forced out. Stakeholders have expressed concerns regarding her performance, both academically and in terms of infrastructure. Since her appointment, there has been a noticeable decline in discipline, with grade ten students reporting widespread incidents of same-sex relationships and sexual harassment perpetrated by older girls. They assert that their attempts to bring these issues to Madam Kamau's attention have been ignored, as she has refused to take any action. Students are now demanding that she clarify her stance on whether she supports the illegal and immoral organization of LGBTQ or if she is a member, which they believe prevents her from acting against its members.

Long Outstanding Accounts Payable Balance

The statement of assets and liabilities and as disclosed in Note 14 to the financial statements reflects accounts payable balance of Kshs.36,883,114.

However, included in the balance are trade payables balance of Kshs.2,872,055 which has been outstanding for between one (1) year and two (2) years and risks loss of public funds through litigations, interests and penalties.

This was contrary to Regulation a2 () (a) of the Public Finance Management (National Government) Regulations, 2015 which states that, 'service payments shall be a first charge on the Consolidated Fund and the Accounting Officer shall ensure this is done to the extent possible that the government does not default on debt obligations'. ln the circumstances, Management was in breach of the law.

Non-Deduction of Capacity Building Levy

The statement of financial performance reflects total expenditure amount of Kshs.117,298,177.

However, review of expenditure amounting to Kshs.50,178,496 revealed that the School did not deduct and remit the public procurement capacity building levy estimated to Kshs.15,054 (0.03% of Kshs. 50,178,496). Further, the penalty of 5% of the outstanding levy amounts remains unpaid.

This was contrary to section 3(1) of the Levy Order, 2023 which provides that there shall be paid a levy by a supplier on all procurement contracts signed between the supplier and a procuring entity, at the rate of 0.03% of the value of the signed contract, exclusive of applicable taxes.

ln the circumstances, Management was in breach of the law.

Lack of Signed Opening Minutes

Review of the School's procurement records revealed that the opening minutes were not signed and initialized by all the committee members contrary to section 78(11) of the Public Procurement and Asset DisposalAct,2015 that states that to acknowledge that the minutes are true reflection of the proceedings held, each member of the tender opening committee shall-initial each page of the minutes; append his or her signature as well as initial to the final page of the minutes indicating their full name and designation".

Evaluation reports

The audit review of the evaluation reports for the procurement process for the year under audit revealed that some pages were missing with only the introduction and the recommendation sections indicated.

Further, sections of the report showing how the evaluation took place were missing. This was contrary to Section 80 (4) of the Public Procurement and Asset DisposalAct, 2015 which states that, "the evaluation committee shall prepare an evaluation report containing a summary of the evaluation and comparison of tenders and shall submit the report to the person responsible for procurement for his or her review and recommendations".

 

Failure to Issue Professional Opinion Prior to Award

Review of the procurement process for all the 2024-2025 procurements revealed that no professional opinion was issued by the Accounting Officer prior to the award of the contract. This contravened the provision of Regulation 79 (1) of the Public Procurement and Asset Disposal Regulations, 2020 which states that, "upon receipt of the evaluation report and professional opinion, the accounting officer shall take into account the contents of the professional opinion and shall within a day, in writing approve award to the successful tenderer".

Lack of an lnspection and Acceptance committee

The audit review of procurement records revealed that there was no evidence of an inspection and acceptance committee established to verify goods, work or services received prior to payment. This was contrary to Section a8 (1) of Public Procurement and Asset Disposal Act, 2015 which states that, "a procuring entity to establish an inspection and acceptance committee responsible for verifying goods, works or services before acceptance".

Procurement of Goods Outside the Approved Procurement Plan

The statement of financial performance reflects total expenditure of Kshs.117,298,177 for the year under review.

However, audit examination revealed that goods amounting to Kshs.11,987,260 were procured during the year without evidence of being in the approved and duly signed procurement plan in accordance with the prescribed guidelines. ln the circumstances, Management was in breach of law.

Late Transfer of lnfrastructure Funds from Operations Bank Account

The statement of financial performance reflects government grants for operations amount of Kshs.13,143,951 as disclosed in Note 2 to the financial statements from the Ministry of Education credited in the operations bank account.

Contrary to the Ministry of Education Circular Ref. No: MOE.HQS/31101181 (112) of 15 November 2022 which directed that maintenance and improvement funds be transferred to the school infrastructure account fifteen (15) days upon receipt of the funds in the operations account. The funds were transferred to lnfrastructure account beyond the stipulated.

Long Outstanding Accounts Receivable Balance

The statement of assets and liabilities reflects accounts receivable balance of Kshs.9,001,002 in respect of fees arrears as disclosed in Note 13 to the financial statements. lncluded in the balance is accounts receivable balance of Kshs.3,134,368 which had been outstanding for more than one (1)year.

However, there was no policy on the impairment of long outstanding fees arrears casting doubt on full recoverability of the accounts receivables balance. ln the circumstances, the existence of effective mechanisms for debt management could not be confirmed.

 

 

Comments